GAD Newsletter August 2009This is a featured page

MESSAGE FROM THE CHAIR
Are you curious about the gender gap in Thai education? Have you noticed a gender gap in Thai
education? Could you identify what you think it is? Not surprisingly there is no official research on
what specifically divides boys and girls in Thai schools and how cultural norms surrounding gender
affect performance by either group. But if you had to consider the classrooms you have visited as a
volunteer, ask yourself, “What big differences do I see?” Many of contributors to this issue of
the GAD Newsletter’s identify female students as consistently scoring higher on assessments given by
teachers and volunteers. However, this is not to say that “Thai girls are smarter than boys.”
Because we have found no official Thai research related to gender and test scores and because most
Peace Corps volunteers teach English, we cannot say whether male or female students score higher
across the range of subjects. It is commonly accepted in cognitive psychology that language learning is
a function of the left hemisphere of the brain as are math and science. Does this mean that if female
Thai students are stronger in English they are also stronger in math and science? There is no research
to support any of such claims. As an English teacher in several Thai classrooms, what I personally
observe, are my female students falling over their desks to ask and answer questions in English,
begging to play games, staying after class to ask grammar questions so that their writing assignments
will be perfect, (rather than just mostly correct) and showing that their enthusiasm for English far
exceeds that of my male students in every way.
In The Penguin Atlas of Women in the World, Joni Seager noted Thailand as having between 75 and 94
percent of girls enrolled in school in 2005. China, India, Laos, and the United States, among others, are
listed as having 95 percent or more of girls enrolled in school in 2005. Is it that school, historically
reserved for boys, is more precious to girls because they have had to earn the right to attend? Another
of the atlas’s maps notes that between 40 and 59 percent of university students in Thailand are girls,
which is the same percentage as China, Laos and the United States, and higher than the 20 to 39
percent of female students in higher education in India.
Are we simply making assumptions that Thai girls are more driven, and therefore, are we giving them
more positive attention in school? Is it culturally acceptable to put the responsibility for succeeding
academically on students rather than on teachers and parents?
This issue of the GAD Newsletter asks all these questions and more as it considers the achievement gap
between Thai girls and boys in school. As you read we ask you to consider the situation in your own
classrooms, what conclusions you make and what we as volunteers can do to ensure that every student
that we meet gets the most academically from our teaching and the example we provide.
-Angela Wyche
Asking Students

"DO BOYS AND GIRLS LEARN THE SAME OR DIFFERENTLY?" by Kelly Beach
Is there a difference between the ways that boys and girlslearn in the Thai classroom? In a perfect world whereeveryone is equal, boys and girls learn the same informationat the same rate and test scores reflect gender-neutral equalityin knowledge. In Thailand a noticeable gap between thegenders occurs. In most cases, the girls score higher on tests,are more attentive in class and are more assertive in theireducation. Why does this occur? Are Thai cultural norms andexpectations for certain students holding the boys back?
Let’s look at the example of a school with 1,350 students.Because there are over 200 sixth graders, students have beensplit up into 6 classes ranging from highest test scores tolowest, based on aptitude tests. In the highest class, there are26 girls and 13 boys. In the lowest class the numbers are theopposite, with 24 boys and 12 girls. This is the second yearthat I have witnessed more girls than boys in the highest classand more boys than girls in the lowest class. This is normal inthe schools here.
At a smaller school with approximately 150 students in thesame area, a sixth grade classroom has 17 girls and 7 boys. While most of the girls in the class can read and have a simplegrasp of phonics, none of the boys can read. They are oftenfound outside cleaning the schools or helping set up and moveitems around for sports day, school ceremonies, or any specialevent. This is the role of the older male students in the school.Unfortunately, it takes them away from valuable learning timein the classroom… time that is not gained back.
I wanted to get a Thai point of view on the division of theclasses and a possible reason that the boys kept scoring lower overall. Although the teachers recognize that there is somedivision, I seem to get a “Mai bpen rai” answer about whyand how to fix the issue. The best answer I received was, “It’sThai culture,” which is the normal response I get when askinga question about the country.
The students however were more vocal and had more ideasabout what was happening with gender in the schools. Idecided to talk to the students in both the highest and lowestscoring classrooms. When asked if they thought that boys andgirls learned differently most students responded with asimple, “No”. When asked more specific questions, theiranswers seemed to change (see chart on below). Some girls,who tend to be more vocal and therefore participate moreoften, felt strongly that girls learned more than boys becausethey pay more attention in class. While I highly value mystudents’ opinions and can see that in their world,“girls are more serious than boys,” there are several theoriesto consider.
In most cases, development occurs later for boys than forgirls. Physiologically, girls mature faster than boys. Becausecertain aspects of intellectual development can’t occur untilthe physical structures are complete, girls tend to developsome abilities earlier than boys. Furthermore, studies haveshown that girls set off to a faster start in language and inother aspects of cognitive performance (“The Developmentof Sex Differences.” E.E. Maccoby, 1966). Basically, girls arelearning faster than boys because they can. Once the studentsmature and the boys catch up to the girls, the differences indevelopment level out. We usually see this leveling outaround the time students begin matayome.
Girls are much more independent learners in the classroom, spendingmore time on listening and paying attention. Because many Thaiteachers cover more than one class, leave the classroom during class,miss meetings or sit down at a desk instead of walking around tomonitor, students who are independent will naturally do better in thissetting. Learning in a Thai classroom versus a westernclassroom requires more attentiveness and task persistence since thestudents often have to regulate their own time on task and personal
accountability for their own learning.
A majority of Thai classrooms use a teacher-centered approach. Thistype of lecture-based, note-taking, reading straight from abook approach can be fine for visual and auditory learners, but tendsto lose the more tactile (kinesthetic) student. Boys in Thailand tendto be more active than the girls and therefore could benefit from amore tactile teaching approach. Until that happens, some students arenot having an educationally stimulating experience in the classroom.This can lead students to tuning out, not trying as hard or acting outwhile learning. This behavior can lead to lower success withindependent work and to lower test scores.
But perhaps they are learning differently because they are looking attheir futures differently. Students have different idea about theircapacity to continue education past a matayome level. Some studentsknow what their occupations will be already. They may be helpingwith the family farm, or working in the family store. I tend to see thismore with boys than girls in the small villages. In fact, some studentsknow that their families will not be able to afford to send them to auniversity. Since some students see their future as pre-determined,putting the time and effort into learning is not worthwhile if they willnot need it in their daily life.
Another reason a majority of girls do better academically is that theyare seen as the leaders of the school. Girls tend to volunteer morequickly than boys. In the classroom, the girls tend to be the ones toshow off their academic skills and many teachers tend to choose thefirst person to volunteer or raise a hand, so the girls get picked first.In the case of after school clubs, at the larger school at my site thereare 31 girls and 11 boys who volunteered to study English for anextra hour. At the smaller school, 10 girls and no boys chose to stayafter school to practice their English. At a volunteer program at thelocal matayome school which teaches reading to elementary kids, 18girls showed up, but no boys showed up to the meeting. Because girlsare putting in more effort, they are reaping more benefits,educationally speaking.
My final questions posed to the boys in particular in the highest andlowest classrooms at the larger school were these: What wouldmake you want to pay attention? How do you want to learn? Whattype of teacher do you want? The resounding response was, “Gamesand songs. Funny teachers.” And doesn’t this make sense? Of course
the students will participate more if we turn learning into a game. Ofcourse they will think more critically if they are asked to create,design and come up with new ideas. Songs with total body responseswork because, well, they’re fun. If effort is made to be in theclassroom, motivating all students, making sure lessons are student -centered and both genders are being encouraged to growacademically without “mai bpen rai” allowances being made, then we
might just see a shift.
Kelly Beach, Master’s degree in Early Childhood Education



medinakansas
medinakansas
Latest page update: made by medinakansas , Aug 21 2009, 1:18 AM EDT (about this update About This Update medinakansas Edited by medinakansas


view changes

- complete history)
More Info: links to this page
There are no threads for this page.  Be the first to start a new thread.

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)